Premier League

Premier League must review the ludicrous handball law that could relegate Fulham

Scott Parker's side were denied a point by a decision that was correct by the letter of the law but not in the spirit of the game.

8:52pm on Thursday 4th March 2021
Robin Bairner

If Fulham are relegated from the Premier League this season by one point or less, they will look back at Thursday night’s 1-0 defeat against Tottenham and curse their luck – and the ludicrous state of the handball law.

Josh Maja thought he had equalised midway through the second half for Scott Parker’s side, who had spent the first period under pressure but came out and dominated the second 45.

The on-loan Bordeaux striker’s joy was short lived, though. VAR proved that in the build up to the goal, the ball had struck the hand of team-mate Mario Lemina.

Fulham v Tottenham: Player Ratings, Match Stats, Player Stats

Now, this was not a deliberate act of handball. Indeed, the ball was rifled at the midfielder from point-blank range by Davinson Sanchez.

It was not even a case whereby Lemina had his hand outside of the silhouette of his body. His arm was glued to his side and had it not been there – ironically in a position the laws would likely deem ‘unnatural’ – the clearance would likely have cannoned off his thigh in any case.

Unfortunately for Fulham, the law states that any handball that results in a goal, accidental or not, is cause for punishment.

Even more unfortunately for Parker’s luckless troops, VAR was on hand to study the minutiae of the incident. Had it not been employed, there is little chance than any of the on-field officials would have paid any heed to Spurs’ hopeful claims of foul play.

Perhaps the most ludicrous aspect of the whole incident, however, is that had the metaphorical boot been on the other foot – that Maja had attempted a shot that had struck Sanchez’s arm in a similar position – the laws would have instructed the referee to turn a blind eye to it.

So, this is a case of an infringement that is quite literally a foul in one area of the pitch but not in another.

It is a crazy state of affairs.

The Premier League sensibly acted to eradicate such punishment on defenders, albeit at a rather bizarre mid-season point, but their action did nothing to help offensive players. It was an oversight as ridiculous as the current law.

When this loophole is finally closed – as it must surely be – it will come too late for Fulham, for whom it could cost their Premier League football.

Latest news

Premier League

Premier League top scorers 2021/22: Bruno Fernandes joins leaderboard but Salah remains in control

The Liverpool forward leads the race for Golden Boot glory despite being at the AFCON, while the Man Utd star scored a double.

  • 12 hours
Predicted XI

Havertz and Mount to start? How Chelsea could line up against Brighton

Chelsea manager Thomas Tuchel will have to make notable changes to the side that lost 1-0 to Manchester City on Saturday

  • 22 hours
Premier League

Premier League Table: Man City look unstoppable but Liverpool cling on to hope

Manchester City look to be romping to another Premier League title, but Liverpool are clinging onto hope after winning on Sunday.

  • 1 day
Predicted XI

How Real Madrid could line up against Athletic Bilbao

Real Madrid face Athletic Bilbao in the final of the Spanish Super Cup in Saudi Arabia

  • 2 days
Predicted XI

How Liverpool could line up against Brentford in the Premier League

Liverpool are still without Mohamed Salah and Sadio Mane due to their participation in the Africa Cup of Nations

  • 2 days
Predicted XI

Ronaldo fit - How Man Utd could line up against Aston Villa

Cristiano Ronaldo missed Man Utd's last match due to a hip problem but should feature in the Premier League

  • 3 days

Most read