Rules

Has the handball rule in the Premier League quietly changed again?

The sight of VAR waving away a penalty against Liam Cooper was refreshing and gives hope that there's been tweaks made

 
10:00pm on Sunday 22nd November 2020
By
Paul Macdonald

Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang is running towards him at pace.

Liam Cooper slides in to make the block. The ball bounces up onto his arm and clearly strikes it. The referee presses his ear. Cooper takes a breath. There's a VAR check, but it's brief. No penalty. And we all move on.

And it wasn't a penalty. You can see from the still image above that the ball clearly did strike him on the arm but Cooper was sliding to block the shot and was not in control, but couldn't possibly mean to handle it. We are all content that this is the case.

Yet it isn't in keeping with anything that's happened in the season so far. As Eric Dier against Newcastle and Joel Ward against Everton proved, IFAB's literal interpretation of the offside law was being ruthlessly applied.

Dier wasn't even facing in the right direction and when jumping for the header, yet Carroll's nod-down onto his arm was penalised. Likewise for Ward; he would have to have removed his arm to avoid giving the penalty away.

The Premier League hinted at a 'softening' of the handball rule back in September when outrage at the decisions being made was at its peak. But we still saw some questionable calls after that, so it could be the case that the Premier League have waited until this round of fixtures to be a little more forgiving towards players.

An incident like Cooper's would have been penalised before, and indeed Danny Rose had a spot kick awarded against him in the Champions League quarter-final against Manchester City for an almost identical incident.

The Premier League, when they make reverse tweaks to decisions, very rarely make a song and dance about them; rather they make them without anyone really knowing that they have been introduced.

And the sharpness of the decision made by both Taylor and VAR - barely even countenancing the idea that a penalty could be given for something so accidental, is encouraging. Hopefully a degree of common sense is returning to the process.

Latest news

Premier League

Premier League injuries and suspensions: David Luiz an Arsenal doubt

Check out our regularly updated list tracking all of the latest unavailable players in England's top division.

  • 14 hours
Predicted XIs

How Barcelona and Atletico Madrid could line up in La Liga showdown

The title race in Spain is set to go down to the wire, with both Barca and Atleti still in the mix to be crowned champions

  • 21 hours
Match Preview

Premier League team news: How Liverpool could line up against Southampton

Jurgen Klopp has no new injury concerns coming into this one as Liverpool aim to keep their Champions League qualification hopes alive

  • 21 hours
Predicted XIs

Premier League team news: How Manchester City and Chelsea could line up

Pep Guardiola's side have the chance to wrap up the Premier League title when the Blues visit the Etihad Stadium over the weekend

  • 22 hours
Player Ratings

Arsenal 0-0 Villarreal Player Ratings: Saka and Odegaard struggle as Arsenal fail to reach Europa League final

Mikel Arteta's Arsenal side failed to reach the final of the Europa League on Thursday after struggling to overcome a strong Villarreal side

  • 1 day
Player Ratings

Roma 3-2 Manchester United Player Ratings: De Gea shines in defeat as Solskjaer’s side reach Europa League final

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s Man Utd side qualified for the final of the Europa League despite losing to Roma on Thursday evening

  • 1 day

Most read