Premier League

Are Everton better with or without James Rodriguez in the side?

Carlo Ancelotti's side have contrasted wildly with and without James Rodriguez in the side throughout this season's Premier League.

11:47am on Wednesday 23rd December 2020
Stefan Bienkowski

Ahead of tonight’s League Cup clash with Manchester United the only news line that has been of any interest to Everton fans is whether or not James Rodriguez will be fit to take part in the clash at Goodison Park.

The Colombian international has missed Everton’s last three games due to a calf injury, following an impressive start to life in England and at the heart of Carlo Ancelotti’s impressive team.

However, Everton haven’t exactly struggled since James was resigned to the injury list and even before that there were murmurs from some quarters suggesting that what Ancelotti’s side may gain in the midfielder’s playmaking they undoubtedly lose in tactical stability and an ability to grind out results.

29 yrs - W (R), M (C) - Everton
JavaScript chart by amChartsLDefendingCreativePassingAttackingShootingDecisiveAerialsPhysical10-10-5051015100%
Played matches
Shots P90
Shots On target P90
Successful passing %
Final third passes P90

Those discenters may have a point. Since James picked up an injury Ancelotti’s team have gone from languishing in ninth in the Premier League table up to fourth, just five points off rivals and league leaders Liverpool.

And they haven’t done this with nine easy points against relegation fodder either. The first James-less match was at home to in-form Chelsea, where Ancelotti’s team put on a hit-and-run masterclass in stealing an early goal and frustrating their guests throughout the full 90 minutes. Then came a comprehensive 2-0 victory over Leicester City and then a 2-1 win in London against Arsenal.

Indeed, even when we include the 2-1 defeat to Newcastle that James missed out on through injury earlier in the season, we still find Everton’s points per game average standing at 2.25 without the Colombian midfielder. With James in the side this season that average drops down to 1.7.

When we look a little deeper at Everton’s stats in this season’s Premier League we do seem to see notable changes in how Ancelotti’s side play with and without James in the side.

Three goals and three assists in 10 league games to date clearly showcases a player with plenty of attacking talent and as such Everton do seem to score far more goals with James in the side. So far this season they’ve averaged 1.9 goals per game with James and just 1.5 without him.

However, as encouraging as that may seem for Everton fans, there certainly seems to be a downside to it as well. Particularly in the team’s ability to properly defend and keep out goals down the other end of the pitch.

While Everton’s goal scoring may improve with James in the team, their defensive stats get drastically worse. In four games without him this season they’ve conceded on average just 0.5 goals per game. With him in the side that number shoots up to 1.6.

Perhaps the most illustrative way of comparing Everton’s contrasting performances can be found in the fact that their goal difference with and without James is exactly the same - +3 - despite the fact that they’ve played 10 games with him and just four without.

Whether Everton are more exciting and entertaining to their fans with James in the team is unquestionably up for debate, but so far this season it seems to suggest that Ancelotti’s side are far sturdier in defence, harder to beat and far more productive in the league when he isn’t in the starting XI.

Latest news

Player Ratings

Spain 0-0 Sweden Player Ratings: Morata misfires as La Roja held

Spain dominated their Euro 2020 opener against Sweden in Seville but were guilty of missing some fine opportunities.

  • 6 hours
Player Ratings

Scotland 0-2 Czech Republic Player Ratings: Stunning Schick scores from halfway line

Scotland's first game at a major international tournament in 23 years ended in defeat as they lost 2-0 to a Patrik Schick-inspired Czech Republic.

  • 13 hours
Predicted XI

Ronaldo, Jota to start but Cancelo out - How Portugal could line up against Hungary

Portugal manager Fernando Santos will have to shuffle his defence after Manchester City defender Joao Cancelo tested positive for COVID

  • 15 hours
Predicted XI

Benzema fit - How France and Germany could line up in Euro 2020 Group F

The biggest fixture of the European Championship so far takes place on Wednesday as two juggernaut nations do battle

  • 16 hours
Player Ratings

Netherlands 3-2 Ukraine Player Ratings: Wijnaldum stars in five-goal thriller

Netherlands produced a thrilling 3-2 success in their Euro 2020 opener against Ukraine, with Gini Wijnaldum an outstanding performer.

  • 1 day
Player Ratings

England 1-0 Croatia Player Ratings: Phillips England's star man in narrow win

The Leeds man has been schooled by Marcelo Bielsa and he provided the most impactful performance on a hot day at Wembley

  • 1 day

Most read