Barcelona

The Arthur and Pjanic swap - a good deal?

Juventus and Barcelona have both got their respective man, but how do both players compare in terms of profile?

9:00am on Saturday 4th July 2020
By
Gonzalo Obando

Its official; Barcelona and Juventus have officially completed the swap deal of Arthur Melo and Miralem Pjanic, at valuations of €72 million and €60 million, respectively.

The debate of whether this was a good deal for both sides is a difficult question to answer without considering several key categories. What do Barcelona and Juventus gain and lose from the trade? And what about the economics of the deal?

Let’s take a look.

Although Arthur and Pjanic have similar goals and assists tally this year in their respective leagues, Arthur’s total Expected Goals and Assists (xG and xA) edged out Pjanic despite playing ~700 less minutes this season.

Arthur is the more active and able player in the attacking third, Pjanic impacts the game more defensively and from deeper positions during the build-up phase.

Arthur vs Pjanic in 2019/20

StatArthurPjanic
Mins1,1231,812
Goals + Assists65
xG + xA33
xG per 900.10.04
xA per 900.140.08
*League minutes only

Arthur’s dribbling & key passing ability

What’s abundantly clear from watching Arthur play, and is further confirmed by the data, is just how good his dribbling ability is - he is one of the best central midfielders in Europe at this.

Apart from Arthur's high dribble success rate of 88% v Pjanic’s 70%, the progressive distance that Arthur achieves carrying the ball P90 minutes is close to 185 yards (v Pjanic’s 99 yards).

23 yrs - M, DM (C) - Barcelona
81
Defending
Creative
Passing
Attacking
Shooting
Decisive
Aerials
Physical
JavaScript chart by amChartsLDefendingCreativePassingAttackingShootingDecisiveAerialsPhysical10-10-5051015100%
1185
Played matches
21
Touches P90
93.42
Tackles P90
1.22
Dribbles P90
2.43
Interceptions P90
0.15
Successful passing %
92%
Final third passes P90
25.67

He also averages around six progressive yards per carry (in the top quartile for all La Liga central midfielders), compared to Pjanic’s four progressive yards per carry (the lowest in Serie A).

Finally, Arthur has proven himself to be a quality passer, particularly in the final third. Arthur is excellent at picking out penetrating balls into players in central areas and then moving to support the initial pass with further link-up play.

However, what’s most impressive is that Arthur currently generates the second highest key pass conversion rate for midfielders in La Liga, which also further confirms his quality of distribution in attacking zones.

Pjanic's defensive ability & build-up passing

30 yrs - M, DM (C) - Juventus
79
Defending
Creative
Passing
Attacking
Shooting
Decisive
Aerials
Physical
JavaScript chart by amChartsLDefendingCreativePassingAttackingShootingDecisiveAerialsPhysical10-10-5051015100%
1972
Played matches
25
Touches P90
90.05
Tackles P90
1.92
Dribbles P90
0.59
Interceptions P90
1.28
Successful passing %
90%
Final third passes P90
23.00

So Barcelona are losing a more ‘attacking-minded’ central midfielder but what do they get out of Pjanic? Well, they appear to be getting a more defensive midfielder with slightly more impactful passing in the build-up.

Defensively, Pjanic’s tackling distribution is nicely balanced across the three thirds of the pitch and looks similar to Sergio Busquets’ profile, while Arthur closely resembles Frenkie de Jong but slightly less active in the mid and attacking thirds.

In terms of build-up, both Arthur and Pjanic participate in around 10% of their team’s average total passes P90 which is significant, however, upon closer inspection we find that 17% of those passes are backward passes for Arthur, while only 13% for Pjanic.

Unlike Arthur, Pjanic fully offsets his backward passes with a higher amount of progressive passes P90. Arthur is a superb passer as we have confirmed above, with 70+ passes P90 and 91%+ accuracy, but is arguably less purposeful in the build-up phase compared to Pjanic.

Who is getting the better deal?

Barcelona appear to be assigning a fairly conservative price relative to Arthur’s contributions and could arguably be demanding more.

Arthur averages 67 successful defensive and passing actions P90, more than players like Casemiro and Tanguy Ndombele. Pjanic on the other hand, who is much older and whose average contributions tally is relatively low compared to Arthur, is being sold to Barcelona with not too much difference between the valuations.

It is not a secret that Barcelona are suffering from cash flow problems, and that the accounting of this deal is essential to ensure they have the ability to do some business this summer. As a result the facts suggest that Juventus have executed the stronger deal, as they have essentially signed a young promising player whose value has sure potential to continue to rise, while also being able to sell Pjanic at a very rich valuation relative to his age and productivity.

And although Barcelona have acquired a top midfielder, at these valuation levels, it appears Barcelona might have signed an age-and-value peaking player with limited time to make an impact at the Camp Nou.

Latest news

Predicted XI

Fati out injured? How Barcelona could line up against Bayern Munich

Xavi's Barcelona side will have to be at their very best to overcome serious injury concerns and beat Bayern Munich

  • 11 hours
Predicted XI

Lukaku to start? How Chelsea could line up against Zenit St Petersburg

Thomas Tuchel will be expecting his Chelsea side to bounce back from defeat with a confident performance in the Champions League

  • 11 hours
Predicted XI

Ronaldo and Sancho dropped? How Man Utd could line up against Young Boys

Manchester United manager Ralf Rangnick is set to make wholesale changes to his team ahead of their clash with Young Boys

  • 11 hours
European Golden Shoe

European Golden Shoe 2021/22: Lewandowski still leads but Haaland returns with a bang

Robert Lewandowski has scored the most goals from Europe's top five leagues so far this campaign

  • 1 day
Premier League

Premier League top scorers 2021/22: Salah continues comfortable lead at the top

Liverpool forward Mohamed Salah is leading the race for Golden Boot glory on 13 goals in 15 games for his club

  • 1 day
Predicted XI

Messi rested, Neymar out – How PSG could line up against Club Brugge

PSG will play out a dead rubber in the Champions League without Neymar, and likely without Lionel Messi.

  • 1 day

Most read