'The game has gone mad' - players and coaches attack 'nonsensical' VAR

Another day of disgraceful decisions has led to increased criticism of the totally out-of-sync system that simply isn't working

4:00am on Monday 19th October 2020
Paul Macdonald

If you're still willing to defend the implementation of VAR at this point, then you're part of the problem.

The farcical decisions that blighted the thrilling 2-2 draw in the Merseyside derby between Everton and Liverpool led to ire not only from the players and coaches directly involved, but from people with no connection to the game.

Virgil Van Dijk's ACL injury suffered at the hands of a vicious Jordan Pickford lunge wasn't even reviewed because of an offside in the build-up, an issue that Liverpool have asked the Premier League for an official response on.

And Sadio Mane's illogical, simply unfounded offside in the final minute robbed the Reds of the victory and led toall fans questioning just how we have allowed this to happen to football.

Jurgen Klopp was very clear in his criticism of the decision, saying afterwards: "I'm a big supporter of VAR but you expect them to make the right decisions. I've done 10 interviews and everyone has told me it's not offside. That doesn't lift my mood."

But the farcical nature of the decision-making process made by faceless, unaccountable individuals leaving everything to the technology and hoping that they, personally, never have to take responsibility for a decision, led to criticism from other professionals.

Cesc Fabregas summed up the mood of most people watching:

While discussing specifically the Van Dijk tackle, former Liverpool player Luis Garcia called for an ex-professional to be added to the VAR team - you know, somehow who actually understands football and physical contact, instead of someone who has never been anywhere near a tackle in their lives.

And the final word was left to Jordan Henderson, who was denied the winning goal in a derby by the most marginal of offsides :

And yet no-one will explain it. There will be no public figure arriving to explain these decisions, everything will remain behind closed doors and it will be brushed under the carpet until the next stupid decision arises. Because that's what IFAB, with the referees complicit, do.


VAR represents the first regressive change to the offside rule in history

We are killing players - Pep Guardiola agrees that the football calendar has to change

Latest news


Zlatan Ibrahimovic in dig at FIFA video game franchise

Milan forward Zlatan Ibrahimovic has taken aim at the video game manufacturer for using images of him without permission.

  • 34 minutes
Premier League

The Aubameyang statistics that should have Arsenal worried

With Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang failing to fire, Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta needs to find a solution for what is an increasingly worrying trend.

  • 2 hours
Champions League

PSG must do Neymar’s work for him against RB Leipzig – Tuchel

Neymar is set to start in PSG's vital Champions League match with RB Leipzig, though his coach admits that he is not fully fit.

  • 2 hours
Champions League

Neymar and Mbappe to start – How PSG could line up against Leipzig

A welcome sight for PSG fans as their two star men return ahead of must-win clash in Group H.

  • 5 hours
Predicted XI

Defensive crisis - How Juventus could line-up against Ferencvaros

Andrea Pirlo is missing three senior central defenders for the match in the Champions League this midweek

  • 6 hours
Predicted XI

Sancho back in the XI – How Dortmund could line up against Club Brugge

The Englishman missed the German side’s last match but should be back in midweek for Champions League duties

  • 6 hours

Most read