Primera Division

Van Gaal unsure if Memphis can succeed at Barca

The Dutch coach worked with the player with the Netherlands and Manchester United

2:40pm on Thursday 10th September 2020
Martin Macdonald

Louis van Gaal admits there has always been a question mark surrounding the prowess of Memphis Depay, and has questioned if the player has what it takes to succeed at Barcelona.

In the 2019/20 campaign, the Blaugrana failed to win a trophy for the first time in 12 years, with Real Madrid winning La Liga and Bayern embarrassing them in the Champions League.

It was after the loss against the German champions which led to head coach Quique Setien being sacked, to be replaced a few days later by Ronald Koeman.

Koeman has been tasked with revamping an ageing squad, and his two main transfer targets are believed to be Gini Wijnaldum and Memphis.


Man Utd make progress in Sancho pursuit

Klopp: Liverpool can't behave like we're owned by a country or oligarch

Ozil names his dream team-mate XI...and includes just one Arsenal player

Bale set for Premier League move as Madrid to pay 50% of wages

However, Van Gaal has played down Memphis' talents compared to the likes of one current and one former Clasico star, Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo.

Memphis will be a team-mate of Messi's should he sign for Barca, with the Argentine set to stay in Catalunya after previously announcing an intention to leave.

"There's always a question mark," Van Gaal toldTuttoMercatoWeb with regards to Memphis' talent.

"Depay is an interesting player, especially when he's free to play, but we have to consider adapting to a new culture and a new team, and the first year is always the hardest. Look at [Matthijs] De Ligt or Frenkie de Jong.

"Depay has talent, but he's not Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo."

As for Koeman, Van Gaal believes his compatriot has the ability to do a good job, but worries that the Messi saga will hang over his tenure.

"I think he is a good coach, a former Barcelona player and this gives him more credit. It won't be easy because you can never know about the Messi problem," he added.

Barcelona have already sold veteran midfielder Ivan Rakitic this summer, with Luis Suarez and Arturo Vidal two players likely to follow him out the door.

Memphis starred for PSV before earning a big-money move to Man Utd with Van Gaal at the helm. After failing to impress, he signed for Lyon to become their star player and captain.

Latest news

Book Extract

How Jurgen Klopp made Trent Alexander-Arnold a playmaking full-back

In an extract from Lee Scott's book on Jurgen Klopp, we look at how the German evolved TAA's role into something special

  • 1 hour
Premier League

Ancelotti and James helping to dispel the 'intense' Premier League myth

The Italian took umbrage to the suggestion that his playmaker would not be able to adapt to England - and he's dead right

  • 2 hours
Lionel Messi

Luis Suarez is still a top forward - just not for Barcelona

The Catalan giants can't carry so many older players but the Uruguayan is still a superb finisher and has time to go yet

  • 4 hours

Official: Atletico Madrid sign Luis Suarez from Barcelona

The Uruguayan had been rumoured to move to Juventus but when that move broke down, the capital club swooped for the forward

  • 9 hours

Di Maria given four-match ban for spitting, Neymar racism decision delayed

The Argentine has been given a somewhat lenient suspension for the incident in the infamous PSG v Marseille clash earlier this month

  • 12 hours
Champions League

Lewandowski and De Bruyne lead UEFA award nominations...but no Messi or Ronaldo

For the first time in a decade, neither Cristiano nor Lionel Messi is nominated for the UEFA Men's Player of the Year Award

  • 15 hours

Most read

Other interesting players

  1. image description Lionel Messi W (R), F (C)
    Barcelona 99
  2. Liverpool 92
  3. image description Bernardo Silva W (R), M (C)
    Man City 84
  4. Sevilla FC 83
  5. image description Dejan Kulusevski W (R), F (C)
    Juventus 82
  6. image description Rodrygo W (RL)
    Real Madrid 78
  7. Feyenoord 78
  8. image description Douglas Costa W (R), AM (L)
    Juventus 74
  9. image description Suso W (R), AM (C)
    Sevilla FC 74