Real Madrid are a broken team, and Zidane doesn't have the answers

The French coach now has one win in six and he doesn't seem to be able to get Los Blancos playing to any kind of standard

9:36pm on Tuesday 1st December 2020
Paul Macdonald

Real Madrid’s horrendous performance in Shakhtar Donetsk may not spell the end for Zinedine Zidane just yet, but the momentum is only moving in one direction.

Shakhtar did the double over Los Blancos with relative ease, winning 2-0 in a match where Madrid’s utter dysfunction continues to be laid bare.

Dentinho’s goal came as a result of yet another defensive mishap, this time Raphael Varane inexplicably deflecting the ball into the forward’s path, to continue a run of recent aberrations. Thibaut Courtois gifted Alaves victory at the weekend, while Sergio Ramos and Marcelo have also made recent errors.

The lack of intensity, of desire, is striking. Yes, this is a season without fans and with a packed calendar, but this has been Madrid’s default since the very beginning of the campaign. At no point this season have they appeared overly convincing, and what’s more, teams seem confident they can beat them.


Shakhtar Donetsk 2-0 Real Madrid: Varane flops

Madrid racked up 1.4 xG in the contest but nearly half that came from Marco Asensio striking the post from a tight angle in the opening minutes. After that their efforts were from less than optimum positions. Half of their 14 shots came from outside the area, while another two came from oppressive angles. They didn’t create good chances, and it’s not the first time this season.

Zidane does have injuries. With Sergio Ramos out, the dynamic of this defence is already weakened, while Lucas Vazquez’s position as an acceptable right-back stand-in for the missing Dani Carvajal and Alvaro Odriozola lessens by the day. And Nacho, well, he’s just not good enough for this level.

And Varane’s form is a genuine concern.He recorded a 5.3 FC Rating here, the lowest of the match, and it is becoming ever-more obvious that when Ramos isn’t there to talk him through matches he is becoming a liability. His errors that cost Madrid their Champions League clash with Man City last season were seen as uncharacteristic at the time, but they are becoming more and more frequent. It is now just four clean sheets in 15 for this unit that won La Liga last season on the back of their brilliant defensive displays.

Raphaël Varane
D (C) - Real Madrid - 27 yrs
Dec 1, 2020
90Minutes played
1Yellow cards
3Duels won
3Aerials won
86Successfull passes %

Ahead of those problems, Luka Modric wouldn’t have expected to play every week at 35, yet here we are, with Fede Valverde out until February at least. And Zidane’s baffling decision to leave out Casemiro and play Martin Odegaard, a player whose confidence and indeed position within the team has yet to develop, sums up his obtuse thinking. The Frenchman is trying various things to get a spark from this team, but nothing at all is working.

And with Eden Hazard injured - again - the options in attack are once again laid bare. Karim Benzema’s 29 touches show his lack of involvement coming back from his injury while none of Rodrygo, Marco Asensio, Vinicius Jr or Isco are giving this team anything at the moment.

And Zidane doesn't seem to know what to do about any of this. Any formation he tries, any combination of players, nothing is coming off. One win in six is testament to that and maybe it answers a few questions about this team’s ability to coach themselves to back-to-back-to-back Champions League glory, rather than via the innovations of the coach.

Losses to Shakhtar x 2, Cadiz, Alaves and Valencia would be enough to end virtually any other Madrid coach in history, and it may well do for Zidane yet. He announced after the match that he is refusing to resign, and want to continue onwards.

But the games don’t get easier. They face Sevilla and Atletico Madrid in their next two league matches, either side of what is now a must-win Champions League match against Borussia Monchengladbach. Influential Madrid-based newspaper Marca declared that ‘Madrid is a disaster, and no-one is saved’, suggesting that there is no intention to bury Zidane just yet.

But this is a team that is chronically broken, at the end of a cycle, and has no real path to rejuvenation.

Latest news


La Liga Table: Real Sociedad go top as Atletico and Madrid games postponed

There were only two La Liga matches on Saturday evening, with Real Sociedad emerging victorious versus Mallorca

  • 13 hours
Premier League

Premier League Table: Chelsea battle to stay top after Brentford win

Chelsea are the sole leaders at the top of the Premier League after battling hard to earn all three points against Brentford

  • 16 hours
Predicted XI

Pedri still out - How Barcelona could line up against Valencia

Ronald Koeman will need to rely on back-up players as his Barca team look to take all three points from Valencia

  • 1 day
Predicted XI

Lukaku a doubt - How Chelsea could line up against Brentford

Chelsea are sweating over the fitness of Romelu Lukaku for their Premier League London derby versus Brentford

  • 2 days
Predicted XI

Torres injured - How Man City could line up against Burnley

Ferran Torres picked up a fractured foot while on international duty with Spain and will miss a period of action for Man City

  • 2 days
Premier League

No Varane, no Maguire - How Man Utd could line up against Leicester

Manchester United will be without their first choice defensive duo for the visit of Leicester in the Premier League

  • 2 days

Most read