Jude Bellingham

Hey Jude! Dortmund, not Man Utd, is the right move for your future

The sparkling 17-year-old had been linked to Manchester United but looks set to settle for a move to Germany

12:00pm on Wednesday 8th July 2020
Paul Macdonald • PAULMACDFC

Jude Bellingham has just turned 17.

Yet such is Birmingham's faith that their prodigious young talent is a sure thing, he has already collected 2332 Championship minutes this season (at the time of writing). The hype is real.

And hype there is. Manchester United emerged as the prime transfer admirer, with the proposed fee rising through £15m, to £20m, even £25m for a kid who, under FA rules, has only just been able to sign a professional contract.

Discussion about his ability always focuses on his maturity, his personable nature and, of course, his boundless, untapped talent. Bellingham is also represented by his family, who are rightly protective of him and are appreciative of the relationship they have cultivated with Birmingham. All parties are confident of his continued progression.

This all sounds like a consummate example of how a young player should be handled by everyone around him. So what could go wrong?

Well, the wrong move could happen.

Dortmund v Man Utd

When looking at Bellingham's statistics - it's even visible from his heat map - we see a player who is still finding himself, working through the possibilities to find out which position he will eventually settle into. He has been deployed in centre midfield, he's been deployed on the left, deployed on the right, and even as part of a two-pronged strike-force. It's testament to his all-round ability that he has performed well enough in each position to earn his manager Pep Clotet's trust.

Jude Bellingham Heat Map, 19/20

“He has been watched since he was 13 or 14," Clotet, who is departing at the end of the season, said of his player recently.

"For the Middlesbrough game [in October] half of Europe was here [scouting]. He is used to it and I am used to it. It’s his club, he is living a dream that comes from the work that he and a lot of people in the academy put together to reach this level."

The economics mean that Birmingham, who made a £37.5m loss in the 2017/18 and who sold Che Adams to Southampton for £15m in the summer of 2019 to offset more losses to come, would accept a bid anywhere near what was proposed.

Meaning whether Bellingham wanted to stay or not, his club's predicament means he has been forced to make a call. Manchester United may look a more attractive proposition now than perhaps in February, but with Mason Greenwood emerging and Jadon Sancho still on the radar, Bellingham wouldn't be immediately playing games and that's what he needs to continue to develop.

Given it's still difficult to define where Bellingham will play in the future, though he does have six goal contributions (four goals and two assists) this season, statistics are less important than where the development can continue, and where better than Borussia Dortmund? He does like to progress the ball forward wherever possible, but there is a clear estimation of the options available, a sharpness of thought, and an understanding of the team dynamic that places him ahead of many of his peers.

Yes, he sometimes makes the wrong decision and yes, he can drift in and out of matches. But, again, he is 17. As Clotet alludes to, he is learning his trade in one of the top 10 leagues in Europe and going to a place like Dortmund is a decision that is very much correct.

17 yrs - M (LC) - Birmingham
JavaScript chart by amChartsLDefendingCreativePassingAttackingShootingDecisiveAerialsPhysical10-10-5051015100%
Played matches
Shots P90
Dribbles P90
Duels won P90
AVG Rating

A move to a Manchester United, thrilling but dysfunctional in equal measure, would likely be an error. With Brandon Williams and Mason Greenwood breaking through while Marcus Rashford has came to the fore in a team not doing well, there's only so many developing players a club still in transition can handle.

Dortmund's entire set-up is to offer players the type of platform that guarantees them minutes in a top-class league, in an exciting, offensive approach. Sancho is the quite obvious example of what can be achieved, but it's not only him; Giovanni Reyna is himself just 17 and big things are expected, while Christian Pulisic is now showing Chelsea what he learned in his time at Signal Iduna Park.

With respect to the Championship it's sometimes more of a battle physically than tactically, and therefore that's what Bellingham needs to develop. It would be hard to argue with the suggestion that the Bundesliga currently has the most talented crop of players spread throughout the league and Bellingham will relish featuring, regularly, in that environment.

Football is jam-packed with prodigies who were expected to progress from illustrious beginnings - Michael Johnson at Man City, and the Everton duo Michael Branch and James Vaughan, youngest ever Premier League scorers in their times, spring immediately to mind. There are a thousand more who also made the wrong move at the wrong time and will look back with regret.

Bellingham doesn't need to rush a single thing. He'll move when he is good and ready. And he needs to realise that move to Manchester United, at this moment in time, is a threat to everything he wants, and hopes, to be.

Jude Bellingham profile, matches, statistics and positions

Latest news

Predicted XI

How Man Utd could line-up against Brighton

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and his charges are looking to bounce back from their opening round defeat versus Crystal Palace

  • 27 minutes
Predicted XI

How Leeds could line-up against Sheffield United

Marcelo Bielsa's side have been exciting to watch so far and he is notoriously loyal to his starting XI, meaning the team won't change much

  • 57 minutes
Predicted XI

How Barcelona could line up against Villarreal

Ronald Koeman's first competitive match in charge will be the first of a new Barca and new tactical set-up

  • 1 hour
Premier League

The kids aren't alright: EPL ranked bottom for offering minutes to young players

Since 2015, only 7.8% of all minutes played were by players 21 or younger - the lowest of the Big Five Leagues

  • 13 hours

What Juventus' Andrea Pirlo thinks about football

In his thesis the Italian laid out his ideas about the game and it offers an insight into what type of Juve he will try to build

  • 13 hours
Premier League

Ancelotti and James helping to dispel the 'intense' Premier League myth

The Italian took umbrage to the suggestion that his playmaker would not be able to adapt to England - and he's dead right

  • 14 hours

Most read

Other interesting players

  1. image description Brandur Olsen M, AM (C)
    Helsingborg 65
  2. Hertha BSC 65
  3. image description Hicham Faik M, DM (C)
    Al Faisaly 65
  4. Dortmund 65
  5. Gamba Osaka 65
  6. Lanús 65
  7. image description Gustavo Hamer M (C), D (R)
    Coventry City 65
  8. image description Adrien Tameze M, DM (C)
    Verona 65
  9. image description Mirko Bruccini M, DM (C)
    Cosenza 65