Bayern's transfer blueprint that other elite teams should follow

The Bavarians have made a number of shrewd investments in recent years - mostly from the German Bundesliga

9:00am on Sunday 5th July 2020
Aidan Reagh

Real Madrid, Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester City, and Bayern Munich. What do these five clubs have in common? They are among the elite of Europe.

However, one has taken an approach to domination like no other club. Bayern have won their 8th successive title in Germany and could be argued as the best side in the world since Hansi Flick’s arrival. What are Bayern doing differently compared to Europe’s other giants?

Despite spending more than double what Borussia Dortmund and Bayer Leverkusen (the second and third highest average salary sides) spend on players, they are still operating in an incredibly efficient manner compared to the rest of the world.

What are some measures that a club in financial struggles like Barcelona could take to maintain dominance in all competitions while saving money? How could a sleeping giant like Manchester United return to elite performances?

The Bayern methodology

While Bayern have recently seen the likes of Lucas Hernandez (Atletico) and Ivan Perisic (Inter) join from clubs across European borders, the large majority of their players are not only domestic players, but players that Bayern secured from competing clubs for relatively cheap. Manuel Neuer and Leon Goretzka were poached from Schalke (with Alexander Nubel soon to join), Niklas Sule from Hoffenheim, and Joshua Kimmich and Benjamin Pavard from Stuttgart. Not to mention Robert Lewandowski from Borussia Dortmund, of course.

With the squad Bayern has built, there may be some questions over youth integration in recent years, however, a high degree of consistent performance has been accomplished through low-risk player investment. While we all enjoy seeing our club spend large amounts on players, consultancy 21st Club published a study in 2017; 56% of players who were ‘club-record signings’ in the big five leagues since 2010 had established themselves as routine starters.

Interestingly enough, a second and third record high signing had a 63% and 59% chance of becoming a routine starter, while the fourth record high signing had a 55% chance of becoming a regular starter. We can interpret that as a big-money signing only works out just over half of the time.

Bayern has worked to eliminate the gamble by minimizing the financial risks involved in their player acquisitions. Through identifying a number of players performing well in the same competitions that they play in, they have eliminated the risk of “can a player transition to our league?” When Bayern defeated Borussia Dortmund 1-0 on May 26th, only one player in the starting lineup did not have Bundesliga experience prior to a permanent transfer to Bayern Munich, that player being Alphonso Davies.

While other teams may be successful, Bayern have found a way to be more efficient in their success.

How can other teams emulate Bayern’s success?

Due to a higher level of financial capabilities in the Premier League, it will be hard for a sleeping giant like Manchester United or Arsenal to lure their divisional rivals’ best talents with the gift of a much larger contract. Along with that, there is less toleration for mistakes. This typically means that clubs like Manchester United are forced to spend outrageous amounts on household names as an effort to immediately compete.

Manchester City has and will likely continue to spend record amounts to not only attempt to reach the promised land of European success, but also dethrone Liverpool and go back to being the best team in England. This is partially why Phil Foden rarely sees meaningful minutes, because Pep Guardiola cannot afford to gamble on ‘unproven’ talent.


Guardiola needs to get serious with Foden or else let him go

In a post-COVID footballing world, will teams like Manchester City or PSG need to limit spending? Can Real Madrid or Barcelona afford to take a step back and make ‘safer’ player acquisitions at the risk of outside pressure claiming a lack of ambition? Will teams like Manchester United accept that spending large amounts does not always equal success, but rather, spending efficient amounts could lead to a return of title-battling performances?

Football is a rich man’s game. The more financial capabilities you have, the more likely you are to succeed. However, an efficient philosophy based on calculated risk could be the difference between title success and market failure.

Latest news

European Golden Shoe

European Golden Shoe 2021/22: Lewandowski wins again as Mbappe grabs second

The Bayern striker has claimed glory in the award for a second straight year and some big name rivals were also prominent in the European golden boot race.

  • 6 months
European Assists King

European Assists King 2021/22: Mbappe and Muller share award as Messi makes podium

The PSG and Bayern forwards could not be separated in the creative standings as the club season reached its conclusion.

  • 6 months
Premier League

Premier League top scorers 2021/22: Salah and Son share Golden Boot, Ronaldo 3rd

The Liverpool and Tottenham stars have finished level in the final goalscoring standings for England's top flight this season.

  • 6 months
Premier League

Premier League Table: Manchester City beat Liverpool to title

Manchester City claimed the Premier League title on the final day of the season, edging Liverpool into second

  • 6 months

La Liga Table: Sevilla book Champions League qualification

Sevilla have booked their place in next season's Champions League after drawing 1-1 at Atletico Madrid on Sunday evening.

  • 6 months

How Chelsea and Liverpool could line up in FA Cup final

Chelsea's last chance at silverware comes in Saturday's FA Cup final while Liverpool are bidding for a historic quadruple

  • 6 months